Why the choice of supplier matters
Supplier: a business that provides another business with the raw materials, components, stock or services it needs.
- A supplier's performance turns into the buyer's performance, because their late lorry becomes your empty shelf and their weak material becomes your faulty product.
- AQA names three factors in the choice: price, quality and reliability, and a business weighs all three against what it sells and who it sells to.
Price
- The price a supplier charges is a direct cost to the buyer, so a lower price cuts the cost of every unit the business makes or resells.
- That lower unit cost can be passed on as a lower selling price, which helps a business competing on price, or kept as a wider profit margin.
- Aldi's low shelf prices depend on buying own-brand lines from suppliers at a lower price than a rival pays for a branded equivalent.
- The price that matters is the delivered price per unit, so delivery charges, minimum order sizes and bulk discounts all have to be counted in.
- Price is easy to compare, which is exactly why it gets too much weight: it is the one factor printed on a quotation.
Quality
- The quality of what comes in sets a ceiling on the quality of what goes out, because no amount of care in the factory rescues poor materials.
- Poor inputs create faults, and faults cost money twice: once in the wasted materials and staff time, and again in refunds, replacements and complaints.
- Quality also has to be consistent, since a supplier whose materials vary from batch to batch forces the buyer to inspect every delivery.
- Input quality matters most where the business charges a premium price, because a customer paying more expects the product not to fail.
- Dyson charges a high price for its vacuum cleaners, so a supplier of cheap motors that burn out would damage the brand far more than it would save.
- A poor online review reaches thousands of future customers, while the saving on the motor is a few pounds per unit.
Reliability
- A reliable supplier delivers the right goods, in the right quantity, on the day promised, every time, without the buyer having to chase them.
- An unreliable supplier stops production or empties the shelves, so staff and machines stand idle while wages and rent still have to be paid.
- The customer feels the failure, not the supplier, so a Deliveroo restaurant that runs out of an ingredient loses the order and the review.
- Reliability lets the buyer hold less stock, because a business that trusts its deliveries does not need to pay to store a large buffer.
Reliability becomes the deciding factor for any business using just in time, which is covered in the article on just in time and just in case.
Other factors a business weighs
- Delivery time: a short wait between ordering and receiving goods means the business can react to a change in demand instead of guessing weeks ahead.
- Capacity to grow with you: a supplier that cannot double its output will hold the buyer back if the buyer expands, forcing a change of supplier later.
- Payment terms: being given 30 days to pay lets the buyer sell the goods before the invoice falls due, which eases pressure on cash.
- Location: a nearby supplier can deliver more often and at shorter notice, while a distant one is usually cheaper per unit but slower to respond.
Why the cheapest supplier can cost the most
- A low price only saves money if nothing goes wrong, and the costs of poor quality and late delivery are far larger than the pennies saved on each unit.
- Which factor a business ranks first depends on what it sells: a discount retailer puts price first, a jeweller puts quality first, and a sandwich shop puts reliability and delivery time first.
- The usual wording is analyse the factors this business should consider when choosing a supplier, so rank the factors for that business rather than listing every one you know.
- Take each factor through to a consequence, for example an unreliable delivery empties the shelf, which loses the sale and the regular customer.
- Say what the business is giving up, such as paying more per unit to secure a guaranteed daily delivery.
- The mistake to avoid is answering about price alone when the case tells you the product is premium or the deliveries have been late.
- What is a supplier?
- How does a lower supplier price reach the customer?
- Give two costs a business faces when a supplier's quality is poor.
- What does a reliable supplier deliver, and why does it let the buyer hold less stock?
- Why might a jeweller and a discount retailer rank the factors differently?