2.6.1 Impact of competition on businesses
What a market and competition mean
Market: anywhere buyers and sellers come together to trade a good or service.
Competition: the rivalry between businesses selling similar products to the same customers, each trying to win those customers rather than lose them.
- A market can be a physical place such as a high street or a covered market, or entirely online like Amazon; what matters is that buyers and sellers meet there.
- Businesses in the same market chase the same customers, so a customer won by one of them is usually a customer lost by another.
- Competition is an external influence, because no business decides how many rivals it has, what they charge or when a new one opens nearby.
- The more rivals there are, and the more alike their products, the stronger the competition, which is why UK groceries and clothing are fiercely competitive while a village post office is not.
- Tesco, Sainsbury's, Asda and Morrisons sell much the same groceries, so shoppers compare prices item by item.
- As shoppers moved to Aldi and Lidl for lower prices, Tesco launched its Aldi Price Match on hundreds of everyday products.
- Rivals, not Tesco, drove that decision, which is competition acting on the business from outside.
The effects of competition on a business
- Pressure on price: a business cannot charge much more than its rivals for a similar product, because customers compare prices in seconds online.
- Thinner profit margins: prices are held down while the cost of competing goes up, so the profit made on each sale shrinks.
- Pressure to improve quality and service: faster delivery, easier returns, longer opening hours and better trained staff all become necessary rather than optional once a rival offers them.
- Spending on promotion: advertising, loyalty cards and sponsorship have to be paid for whether or not they lift sales, and a rival that spends more can take customers anyway.
- The risk of losing sales, or the business itself: a firm that stops keeping up loses customers, as HMV did when buyers moved to cheaper online sellers and then to streaming.
- Customers gain: competition hands them lower prices, better quality and more choice, which is why the same pressure that squeezes a business is good for the people buying from it.
- Competition is not about how many customers a business has, but about how many businesses are chasing those customers.
- Where products are nearly identical, such as petrol or milk, price does most of the competing; where they differ, brand and quality do more of it.
Competing on price or standing out
- A business meets a rival in one of two broad ways: it competes on price, or it differentiates itself so that price matters less to its customers.
- Cut or match the rival's prices. This keeps price-sensitive customers from switching, but it takes profit off every unit sold, and a bigger rival can cut deeper for longer.
- Improve quality. Better quality justifies a higher price and builds a reputation, though better materials and more checks push costs up.
- Improve customer service. Loyalty built on service is hard for a rival to copy quickly, but it needs more staff, more training and more time spent on each customer.
- Launch new or improved products. Something a rival does not offer gives customers a reason to choose this business first, although development ties up cash with no guarantee that the sales follow.
- Build the brand through promotion. Customers who trust a brand buy for that reason rather than on price, but advertising is a large cost that may never pay back.
- A small firm facing a much larger rival usually looks for a difference to compete on rather than a discount, which is how Gymshark grew against far bigger sportswear brands, on design and social media rather than on being cheapest.
- A price war can leave every business in the market poorer, and the one with the deepest pockets outlasts the rest.
- Aim the response at the rival's weakness, so compete on service against a rival whose service is poor.
When a business faces little or no competition
- Some businesses have minimal or no competition, because customers who want what they sell have nowhere realistic to go instead.
- Where this happens: the only shop in a village, the only petrol station for miles, a cafe inside a hospital or at a motorway service area, and a train operator on a route with no alternative.
- It also happens when a product is genuinely new or protected by a patent, so for a time nobody else is allowed to copy it.
- Higher prices and wider margins: with no rival to undercut it, the business can charge more and keep a larger profit on each sale.
- Less pressure to improve: quality, range, opening hours and service can all slip, because customers cannot easily take their money elsewhere, and there is little reason to spend on new products.
- Customers lose out through higher prices, less choice and slower improvement.
- The comfort rarely lasts. High profits attract new entrants, and technology can open the market up, since online delivery now reaches customers a village shop once had to itself.
- The only shop in a small village can charge more for milk and bread than a Tesco superstore, because the nearest alternative is a bus ride away.
- It feels little pressure to widen its range or open later, so its customers accept less choice than town shoppers get.
- The moment a discount supermarket opens in the nearest town, or a grocery delivery service starts serving the village, that advantage is gone.
- The usual wording is analyse the impact of increased competition on this business, so build a chain from what the rival does to this firm's sales, prices, costs and profit.
- Name the rival, name what it does better, and say which of this business's customers are most likely to switch.
- The mistake to avoid is writing about competition in general when the question names one business in one market.
- What is a market, and what is competition?
- Give three effects of strong competition on a business.
- Why does matching a rival's price protect sales but damage profit?
- Name two situations in which a business faces little or no competition.
- What tends to happen to a business earning high profits with no rivals?
2.6.2 Uncertainty and risk
Risk and uncertainty
Risk: the chance that a business decision goes wrong and leads to a loss, where that chance can be estimated in advance.
Uncertainty: future events a business cannot predict or control, so their likelihood cannot be estimated at all.
- Because a risk can be estimated, a business can weigh the possible loss against the possible reward and decide whether the decision is worth taking.
- Uncertainty cannot be estimated in that way, and a pandemic, a war that sends fuel prices up or a sudden change in the law arrives without warning.
- Every business faces uncertainty, because each decision is taken now and pays off later, and nobody can see or control what happens in between.
- The distinction matters in practice: a risk is planned for with figures, while uncertainty is prepared for by staying flexible and keeping money in reserve.
- When Nando's plans a new restaurant it can estimate the chance of failure from the sales of similar sites, so opening it is a measurable risk.
- No amount of data would have predicted the 2020 lockdowns that closed every restaurant in the country, which was uncertainty.
- The same business therefore manages the first with forecasts and the second with cash reserves and the ability to switch to deliveries.
The risks and uncertainties a business faces
- Changing tastes: what customers want can move quickly, so a fashion retailer that misreads a trend is left discounting stock nobody wants.
- New competitors: a rival can open nearby, or an online seller can reach the same customers from anywhere, and neither event is in the firm's control.
- Economic change: a recession, higher interest rates or rising inflation cut what customers can afford, while the firm's own energy and materials cost more.
- Supplier failure: a supplier can raise its prices, deliver late or go out of business, and a firm relying on one supplier for a key part has to stop production.
- New technology: technology can make a product or a whole way of selling out of date, as streaming did to DVD rental and to the shops that sold discs.
- New legislation: a rise in the legal minimum hourly rate or a new safety requirement raises costs at short notice, and the business has no choice about meeting it.
- Keep risk and uncertainty apart in your answer, because a risk can be estimated and planned for while uncertainty cannot.
- Naming a danger is only half the job; say what it does to sales, costs, cash or profit.
Why entrepreneurs take the risk
- Profit: the reward for accepting the risk is the profit the owner keeps, and a successful business can pay far more than any wage.
- Independence: being your own boss means deciding what to sell, who to work with and which hours to work, with nobody above you to overrule it.
- A gap in the market: an entrepreneur who spots something customers want but cannot get takes the risk to reach them first, as Monzo did by offering banking through a phone app.
- Turning an interest into a living: Ben Francis started Gymshark making gym clothing at home while at university, because it was what he cared about.
- Building something of their own: some want the satisfaction and recognition of creating a business, and some want to provide a service their area lacks.
- James Dyson spent years and thousands of prototypes on a bagless vacuum cleaner that no manufacturer wanted to buy.
- He risked his own money and time with no guarantee of a single sale, which is the cost side of the bargain.
- The reward was ownership of a business now selling across the world, which a salary would never have matched.
How a business can minimise risk
- Market research: finding out whether customers want the product, and what they will pay, before spending money on it means fewer launches fail.
- A business plan and a cash flow forecast: setting out costs, expected sales and the finance needed shows problems early, so a month that is forecast to run short of cash can be covered by arranging an overdraft in advance.
- Testing on a small scale first: a market stall before a shop, or a launch in a handful of stores before a national one, keeps the possible loss small enough to survive.
- Keeping cash reserves: spare cash absorbs a sudden fall in sales or an unexpected bill, which is how many firms rode out the jump in energy costs that closed others.
- Insurance: a premium cannot stop a fire, a theft or a customer claim, but it turns a large unpredictable loss into a small predictable cost.
- Spreading the product range: selling several products means a fall in demand for one does not sink the business, which is why Warburtons sells wraps, crumpets and thins alongside sliced bread.
- Choosing reliable suppliers, and more than one: checking a supplier's record for quality and delivery, then using two suppliers for a key material, means one late delivery cannot halt production.
- Reducing risk costs money as well, in insurance premiums, research fees and cash held back instead of invested.
- Risk can be reduced but never removed, and a business that refuses every risk also refuses every chance to grow.
- The aim is to take only the risks the business could afford to be wrong about.
- A typical instruction is explain how this business could reduce the risk of this decision, so name one method and show how it cuts either the chance of a loss or its size.
- Say whether the danger in the case is a risk that can be estimated or an uncertainty that cannot, because that decides which methods are any use.
- When you are asked to recommend, choose one method and justify it for this business, since a start-up cannot afford what a national chain can.
- What is the difference between a risk and an uncertainty?
- Give four sources of risk or uncertainty that a business faces.
- Why do entrepreneurs take on risk instead of taking a paid job?
- Name three activities that reduce risk, and explain how one of them works.
- Why can a business reduce risk but never remove it?