Skip to content

Course home

Responses to people in authority

Responses to people in authority

EasyMediumHard
123456
Question 3

Source: Whistleblower claims hospital staff 'just followed orders'

A public inquiry into the clinical malpractice scandal at St Jude's Hospital has heard that junior nursing staff who administered inappropriate dosages of sedative medication were "just following orders" from senior medical consultants.

A junior nurse testifying under anonymity stated that clinicians felt unable to challenge the decisions of the Chief Consultant, who wore a distinctive formal white coat and held a prestigious academic title. The inquiry heard that the hospital's rigid hierarchy meant that challenging authority was viewed as insubordination. One email read out to the inquiry from a ward manager instructed staff to "get the patients quietened down by any means necessary, and do not question the clinical lead."

Lawyers representing the affected families argue that individual staff members must take responsibility, but defence representatives argue that the systemic pressure to obey authority made independent decision-making virtually impossible.


Using your psychological knowledge of obedience to authority, suggest a training programme designed to reduce blind obedience among healthcare staff at St Jude's Hospital.

[6]
Markscheme

Responses to people in authority Questions

  1. A Level
  2. /Psychology
  3. /Responses to people in authority

128 exam-style questions on OCR A Level Psychology Responses to people in authority, covering Milgram (1963): Obedience and Bocchiaro et al. (2012): Disobedience and whistle-blowing. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.

Question bank