A researcher investigates compliance and the bystander effect within a virtual corporate environment. Thirty adult participants are recruited under the guise of testing a new "AI-driven remote management platform." Each participant is assigned the role of a "Supervisor" and paired with an automated "Division Manager" (controlled by the researcher) and a "Subordinate Employee" (who they believe is another participant, but is actually a pre-programmed simulation).
During the task, the "Division Manager" instructs the Supervisor to monitor the Employee's data-entry speed. The Supervisor is ordered to administer severe financial penalties (represented as "salary deductions") and send pre-written harsh reprimands to the Employee’s public chat feed whenever their speed drops. As the simulation progresses, the Employee's performance slows, and they send increasingly distressed messages in the chat: "My chest feels extremely tight, I think I am having a medical emergency, please help me."
When participants hesitate, the "Division Manager" sends automated commands: "The system evaluation must proceed. It is essential that you ignore the message and apply the penalty immediately."
Despite exhibiting physiological signs of extreme distress (such as sweating, trembling, and hyperventilating), 75% of the participants complied with all commands. During the post-experimental debrief, several participants expressed intense guilt and voiced ongoing anxiety regarding their own moral choices during the trial.
Assume you have suggested two modifications to this laboratory-style simulation to address either ethical issues (such as protection of participants from psychological distress or the use of deception) or methodological issues (such as the artificiality of the remote corporate task).
Discuss the implications of these suggested modifications on the design and findings of the research.
276 exam-style questions on OCR A Level Psychology Debates, covering Nature/nurture, Freewill/determinism, Reductionism/holism, Individual/situational explanations, Usefulness of research, Ethical considerations, Conducting socially sensitive research, and Psychology as a science. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.