31:I[196793,["/_next/static/chunks/3j194e876w45f.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/060-i_62-vse1.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2epfhfe5im7r6.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2yhf9vq09dqoa.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0p4rexedanx97.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0u008gt6051u7.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1odwrcl12kfnl.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0zkcxwtbsqliz.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/316m85d5s15pp.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2_itvjgqsumf8.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0be1c60akah5d.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3r5hh4t0jf4es.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3ml3vooxhiupb.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1h4wccj42vygd.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/12xoy6h_w_le6.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2os7nxouq91eq.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3ht89vb0p09bm.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3ocoqwe4aht_u.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/32qmkt01ta8b2.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3jpl-42mbad5n.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1bbv7o2-m-0ni.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/097slu7xaeast.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/14kf-an-d2n-e.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/117yqm55h4y_p.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0v4byuex1x38h.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2eoustw-nfu98.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0llqhg6-bxn_b.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/11ryphth5_v5b.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0gvj8_2lj8s8m.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/04zr-wqafvwoa.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2dx-vzwyw9a3g.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2ydqdr10ndcei.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1ku-vdy4ggo41.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1br6ag7ig1vnn.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1bnld2zwzjlzx.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/09_ag440ieydu.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3_o3al2nkyqic.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0k-y_4mcfub-p.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0ewqopfomauzf.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2srfni4gkx9g6.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0odk_0my0_b5-.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0ix6b88ybjhi_.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/00ol_16j3a2oa.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/21sij0j_ujna2.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2fk-2o4srnsgz.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1nnw6yom6-qhh.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/12mv6p8rwcl5o.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1y5xmyjgu8grb.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1c50trxtlnlob.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2e0e0lyynppq_.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/03kujzvz7i588.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3h4suq-9gmzwh.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0m31zgrien991.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/30dopbgd1dkf9.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2hccrcvndngge.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3ghbpnibq2fva.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1lsxkfxy262n-.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/43ajf4ofaeu5y.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/12_xkdi18mnhe.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1ksyn9m68446d.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1__39-dgg7p8-.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3wqp-h5xnebw9.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2y341-r8ncizo.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2s1hkstzlmj2o.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2vg15qyptj-oc.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2wp4esku6l29e.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0mlmsepku9vgc.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0zg1om_k0m5zv.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106"],"Gingerbread"] 33:I[647935,["/_next/static/chunks/3j194e876w45f.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/060-i_62-vse1.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2epfhfe5im7r6.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2yhf9vq09dqoa.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0p4rexedanx97.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0u008gt6051u7.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1odwrcl12kfnl.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0zkcxwtbsqliz.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/316m85d5s15pp.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2_itvjgqsumf8.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0be1c60akah5d.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3r5hh4t0jf4es.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3ml3vooxhiupb.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1h4wccj42vygd.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/12xoy6h_w_le6.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2os7nxouq91eq.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3ht89vb0p09bm.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3ocoqwe4aht_u.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/32qmkt01ta8b2.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3jpl-42mbad5n.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1bbv7o2-m-0ni.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/097slu7xaeast.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/14kf-an-d2n-e.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/117yqm55h4y_p.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0v4byuex1x38h.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2eoustw-nfu98.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0llqhg6-bxn_b.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/11ryphth5_v5b.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0gvj8_2lj8s8m.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/04zr-wqafvwoa.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2dx-vzwyw9a3g.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2ydqdr10ndcei.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1ku-vdy4ggo41.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1br6ag7ig1vnn.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1bnld2zwzjlzx.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/09_ag440ieydu.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3_o3al2nkyqic.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0k-y_4mcfub-p.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0ewqopfomauzf.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2srfni4gkx9g6.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0odk_0my0_b5-.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0ix6b88ybjhi_.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/00ol_16j3a2oa.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/21sij0j_ujna2.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2fk-2o4srnsgz.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1nnw6yom6-qhh.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/12mv6p8rwcl5o.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1y5xmyjgu8grb.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1c50trxtlnlob.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2e0e0lyynppq_.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/03kujzvz7i588.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3h4suq-9gmzwh.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0m31zgrien991.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/30dopbgd1dkf9.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2hccrcvndngge.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3ghbpnibq2fva.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1lsxkfxy262n-.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/43ajf4ofaeu5y.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/12_xkdi18mnhe.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1ksyn9m68446d.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1__39-dgg7p8-.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3wqp-h5xnebw9.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2y341-r8ncizo.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2s1hkstzlmj2o.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2vg15qyptj-oc.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2wp4esku6l29e.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0mlmsepku9vgc.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0zg1om_k0m5zv.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106"],"RecordResourceResume"] 34:I[830476,["/_next/static/chunks/3j194e876w45f.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/060-i_62-vse1.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2epfhfe5im7r6.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2yhf9vq09dqoa.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0p4rexedanx97.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0u008gt6051u7.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1odwrcl12kfnl.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0zkcxwtbsqliz.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/316m85d5s15pp.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2_itvjgqsumf8.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0be1c60akah5d.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3r5hh4t0jf4es.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3ml3vooxhiupb.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1h4wccj42vygd.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/12xoy6h_w_le6.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2os7nxouq91eq.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3ht89vb0p09bm.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3ocoqwe4aht_u.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/32qmkt01ta8b2.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3jpl-42mbad5n.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1bbv7o2-m-0ni.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/097slu7xaeast.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/14kf-an-d2n-e.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/117yqm55h4y_p.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0v4byuex1x38h.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2eoustw-nfu98.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0llqhg6-bxn_b.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/11ryphth5_v5b.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0gvj8_2lj8s8m.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/04zr-wqafvwoa.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2dx-vzwyw9a3g.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2ydqdr10ndcei.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1ku-vdy4ggo41.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1br6ag7ig1vnn.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1bnld2zwzjlzx.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/09_ag440ieydu.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3_o3al2nkyqic.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0k-y_4mcfub-p.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0ewqopfomauzf.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2srfni4gkx9g6.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0odk_0my0_b5-.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0ix6b88ybjhi_.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/00ol_16j3a2oa.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/21sij0j_ujna2.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2fk-2o4srnsgz.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1nnw6yom6-qhh.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/12mv6p8rwcl5o.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1y5xmyjgu8grb.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1c50trxtlnlob.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2e0e0lyynppq_.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/03kujzvz7i588.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3h4suq-9gmzwh.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0m31zgrien991.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/30dopbgd1dkf9.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2hccrcvndngge.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3ghbpnibq2fva.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1lsxkfxy262n-.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/43ajf4ofaeu5y.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/12_xkdi18mnhe.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1ksyn9m68446d.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1__39-dgg7p8-.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3wqp-h5xnebw9.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2y341-r8ncizo.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2s1hkstzlmj2o.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2vg15qyptj-oc.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2wp4esku6l29e.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0mlmsepku9vgc.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0zg1om_k0m5zv.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106"],"FlashcardAccessBranch"] 35:I[315438,["/_next/static/chunks/3j194e876w45f.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/060-i_62-vse1.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2epfhfe5im7r6.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2yhf9vq09dqoa.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0p4rexedanx97.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0u008gt6051u7.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1odwrcl12kfnl.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0zkcxwtbsqliz.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/316m85d5s15pp.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2_itvjgqsumf8.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0be1c60akah5d.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3r5hh4t0jf4es.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3ml3vooxhiupb.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1h4wccj42vygd.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/12xoy6h_w_le6.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2os7nxouq91eq.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3ht89vb0p09bm.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3ocoqwe4aht_u.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/32qmkt01ta8b2.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3jpl-42mbad5n.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1bbv7o2-m-0ni.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/097slu7xaeast.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/14kf-an-d2n-e.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/117yqm55h4y_p.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0v4byuex1x38h.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2eoustw-nfu98.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0llqhg6-bxn_b.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/11ryphth5_v5b.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0gvj8_2lj8s8m.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/04zr-wqafvwoa.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2dx-vzwyw9a3g.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2ydqdr10ndcei.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1ku-vdy4ggo41.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1br6ag7ig1vnn.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1bnld2zwzjlzx.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/09_ag440ieydu.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3_o3al2nkyqic.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0k-y_4mcfub-p.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0ewqopfomauzf.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2srfni4gkx9g6.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0odk_0my0_b5-.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0ix6b88ybjhi_.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/00ol_16j3a2oa.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/21sij0j_ujna2.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2fk-2o4srnsgz.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1nnw6yom6-qhh.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/12mv6p8rwcl5o.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1y5xmyjgu8grb.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1c50trxtlnlob.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2e0e0lyynppq_.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/03kujzvz7i588.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3h4suq-9gmzwh.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0m31zgrien991.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/30dopbgd1dkf9.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2hccrcvndngge.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3ghbpnibq2fva.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1lsxkfxy262n-.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/43ajf4ofaeu5y.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/12_xkdi18mnhe.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1ksyn9m68446d.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/1__39-dgg7p8-.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/3wqp-h5xnebw9.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2y341-r8ncizo.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2s1hkstzlmj2o.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2vg15qyptj-oc.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/2wp4esku6l29e.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0mlmsepku9vgc.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106","/_next/static/chunks/0zg1om_k0m5zv.js?dpl=nogit-1790227106"],"TopicFlashcardRunner"] 23:[["$","$L31",null,{"feature":"flashcards"}],"$L32",["$","$L33",null,{"href":"/a-level/law/aqa/restrictions/flashcards","label":"Restrictions","subjectCode":"a_level_law__aqa","surface":"flashcards"}],["$","$L34",null,{"runner":["$","div",null,{"className":"min-h-0 flex-1 overflow-hidden bg-background","children":["$","$L35",null,{"decks":[{"id":"a769b710-e398-4978-8590-9d4595976b58","title":"Restrictions Flashcards","topicId":"9b3723ba-672c-541e-b5c1-b9104cd15cf5","topicSlug":"restrictions","cards":[{"id":"5d5e87df-95ca-4cc6-8d0f-00354d5ddb57","cardType":"basic","points":2,"front":"Why is a limit on Articles 8, 10 or 11 not automatically a breach?","back":"They are qualified rights: interference may be justified under subsection .2.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"They are qualified rights: interference may be justified under subsection .2.","correct":true,"explanation":"Articles 8, 10 and 11 are qualified rights, so interference can be lawful where it satisfies the relevant restriction test, including the conditions in subsection .2."},{"text":"They are absolute rights: interference can never be justified under subsection .2.","correct":false,"explanation":"Calling these rights absolute wrongly suggests that no restriction can ever be justified. Articles 8, 10 and 11 are qualified, allowing proportionate interference under subsection .2."},{"text":"They are unqualified rights: interference is always justified under subsection .2.","correct":false,"explanation":"These rights are not automatically protected from all state action. They are qualified rights, so interference may be justified when the subsection .2 requirements are met."},{"text":"They are qualified rights: any interference is automatically lawful under subsection .2.","correct":false,"explanation":"The existence of a limit does not itself establish a breach, but neither does it automatically establish legality. These qualified rights require interference to satisfy subsection .2."}]},{"id":"a2428ad9-ea49-4cfd-9cb1-8fc4abd49406","cardType":"cloze","points":null,"front":"For Articles 8, 10 and 11, subsection [ ] gives the right; subsection [ ] gives the restriction test.","back":"For Articles 8, 10 and 11, subsection .1 gives the right; subsection .2 gives the restriction test.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"For Articles 8, 10 and 11, subsection .1 gives the right; subsection .2 gives the restriction test.","correct":true,"explanation":"For each of these qualified rights, subsection .1 states the protected right, while subsection .2 sets out the conditions under which interference may be justified."},{"text":"For Articles 8, 10 and 11, subsection .2 gives the right; subsection .1 gives the restriction test.","correct":false,"explanation":"The subsections are reversed here. Subsection .1 establishes the right, whereas subsection .2 contains the restriction conditions and justification test."},{"text":"For Articles 8, 10 and 11, subsection .1 gives the restriction test; subsection .2 gives the right.","correct":false,"explanation":"The first subsection is not the restriction test. It identifies the protected interest; the second subsection provides the framework for assessing justified interference."},{"text":"For Articles 8, 10 and 11, subsection .2 gives the restriction test; subsection .1 gives the right.","correct":false,"explanation":"Neither subsection is simply an optional provision. The right appears in .1 and the possible restrictions, with their conditions, appear in .2."}]},{"id":"8a20e756-5ada-4fae-8857-edac0f822537","cardType":"cloze","points":null,"front":"State action that [ ] exercise of a Convention right is an [ ].","back":"State action that limits, obstructs, penalises or discourages exercise of a Convention right is an interference.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"State action that limits, obstructs, penalises or discourages exercise of a Convention right is an interference.","correct":true,"explanation":"An interference occurs when state action makes exercising a Convention right more difficult or less attractive by limiting, obstructing, penalising or discouraging its exercise."},{"text":"State action that supports, facilitates, rewards or encourages exercise of a Convention right is an interference.","correct":false,"explanation":"This describes conduct that supports or facilitates a right, not conduct that interferes with it. Interference includes limiting, obstructing, penalising or discouraging its exercise."},{"text":"State action that prohibits, removes, abolishes or prevents exercise of a Convention right is an interference.","correct":false,"explanation":"The definition is not limited to direct prohibition. Indirect discouragement or penalties can also interfere, so the broader formulation includes limiting, obstructing, penalising or discouraging."},{"text":"State action that observes, permits, tolerates or ignores exercise of a Convention right is an interference.","correct":false,"explanation":"These words describe state neutrality rather than an adverse impact on exercise. A measure can interfere without eliminating the right, including by obstructing or discouraging its use."}]},{"id":"b297e6e5-8e2c-41b3-8de7-a57951888512","cardType":"cloze","points":null,"front":"Article 8.1 protects [ ]; Article 10.1 protects [ ].","back":"Article 8.1 protects private and family life, home, and correspondence; Article 10.1 protects freedom of expression.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"Article 8.1 protects private and family life, home, and correspondence; Article 10.1 protects freedom of expression.","correct":true,"explanation":"Article 8.1 protects the listed aspects of personal and domestic life, while Article 10.1 protects the ability to communicate ideas and information through freedom of expression."},{"text":"Article 8.1 protects freedom of expression; Article 10.1 protects private and family life, home, and correspondence.","correct":false,"explanation":"Freedom of expression belongs to Article 10.1, not Article 8.1. Article 8.1 concerns private and family life, home, and correspondence."},{"text":"Article 8.1 protects freedom of assembly; Article 10.1 protects private and family life.","correct":false,"explanation":"Article 8.1 does not generally protect freedom of assembly, and Article 10.1 is concerned with expression rather than correspondence. The protected interests have been confused."},{"text":"Article 8.1 protects freedom of religion; Article 10.1 protects freedom of assembly.","correct":false,"explanation":"Freedom of religion is protected principally by Article 9, while Article 10.1 protects expression. Article 8.1 has the distinct privacy and domestic-life focus stated in the correct answer."}]},{"id":"d85883a7-4cf0-47d0-9406-bc520ebcc7ea","cardType":"basic","points":2,"front":"What feature must an assembly have before Article 11.1 protection is secure?","back":"It must be peaceful; violence may take it outside Article 11.1.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"It must be peaceful; violence may take it outside Article 11.1.","correct":true,"explanation":"Article 11.1 protects assemblies only when they are peaceful. Violence can remove the conduct from the scope of the protected assembly right, although individual circumstances still matter."},{"text":"It must be private; publicity may take it outside Article 11.1.","correct":false,"explanation":"An assembly does not need to be private to receive Article 11.1 protection. The key threshold feature is that it must be peaceful rather than violent."},{"text":"It must be authorised; lack of permission may take it outside Article 11.1.","correct":false,"explanation":"Article 11.1 does not require an assembly to be authorised before protection is considered. Peacefulness is the essential feature identified by the provision."},{"text":"It must be large; a small gathering may take it outside Article 11.1.","correct":false,"explanation":"The size of a gathering is not the defining condition for Article 11.1 protection. A small or large assembly may qualify, provided it remains peaceful."}]},{"id":"74e3c558-4f17-46cd-8dae-357385f9ce33","cardType":"basic","points":3,"front":"What are the three general requirements for restricting Articles 8, 10 or 11?","back":"

Law: in accordance with/prescribed by law.
Legitimate aim: listed in subsection .2.
Necessity/proportionality: justified in a democratic society.

","mcqOptions":[{"text":"

Law: in accordance with/prescribed by law.
Legitimate aim: listed in subsection .2.
Necessity/proportionality: justified in a democratic society.

","correct":true,"explanation":"A restriction must have a legal basis, pursue a legitimate aim listed in subsection .2, and be necessary and proportionate in a democratic society."},{"text":"

Approval: accepted by a public official.
Convenience: useful to the authorities.
Popularity: supported by most people.

","correct":false,"explanation":"A restriction is not justified merely because officials approve it, it is convenient, or it is popular. The test requires lawfulness, a legitimate aim, and necessity or proportionality."},{"text":"

Emergency: used during a serious situation.
Majority support: accepted by most voters.
Generality: applies to many people.

","correct":false,"explanation":"Emergency, majority support, and broad wording do not replace the Convention test. The restriction must still be legally based, pursue a listed aim, and be necessary and proportionate."},{"text":"

Written rule: recorded in legislation.
Public benefit: helps the community.
Equal application: affects everyone alike.

","correct":false,"explanation":"A restriction does not become lawful simply because it is written, beneficial, or imposed equally. It must meet all three requirements: law, legitimate aim, and necessity or proportionality."}]},{"id":"c6eaa189-3ad9-4fd9-8e63-1662aef8943f","cardType":"cloze","points":null,"front":"Article 8.2 uses [ ]; Articles 10.2 and 11.2 use [ ].","back":"Article 8.2 uses in accordance with law; Articles 10.2 and 11.2 use prescribed by law.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"Article 8.2 uses in accordance with law; Articles 10.2 and 11.2 use prescribed by law.","correct":true,"explanation":"Article 8.2 uses the wording “in accordance with law”, while Articles 10.2 and 11.2 use “prescribed by law”. The legal principle is similar, but the wording differs."},{"text":"Article 8.2 uses prescribed by law; Articles 10.2 and 11.2 use in accordance with law.","correct":false,"explanation":"This reverses the wording used in the provisions. Article 8.2 says “in accordance with law”, whereas Articles 10.2 and 11.2 say “prescribed by law”."},{"text":"Article 8.2 uses provided by law; Articles 10.2 and 11.2 use authorised by law.","correct":false,"explanation":"The phrase “provided by law” is not the wording being tested here. Article 8.2 uses “in accordance with law”, and Articles 10.2 and 11.2 use “prescribed by law”."},{"text":"Article 8.2 uses required by law; Articles 10.2 and 11.2 use regulated by law.","correct":false,"explanation":"The phrase “required by law” substitutes a near-synonym for the Convention wording and does not distinguish the Articles correctly. The relevant phrases are “in accordance with law” and “prescribed by law”."}]},{"id":"29acdcc9-2b3c-441c-a369-e4503313e1c5","cardType":"basic","points":3,"front":"What must a legal basis provide to satisfy the law requirement?","back":"

Accessible: people can find the law.
Foreseeable: reasonable prediction of use.
Safeguards: prevent arbitrary discretion.

","mcqOptions":[{"text":"

Accessible: people can find the law.
Foreseeable: reasonable prediction of use.
Safeguards: prevent arbitrary discretion.

","correct":true,"explanation":"The legal basis must be accessible, foreseeable in its operation, and supported by safeguards against arbitrary use of official discretion. These features make restrictions legally controlled and predictable."},{"text":"

Popular: most people support the law.
Simple: everyone understands it immediately.
Permanent: it cannot later be changed.

","correct":false,"explanation":"A law need not be popular, simple, or permanent to satisfy this requirement. It must instead be accessible, foreseeable, and protected by safeguards against arbitrary discretion."},{"text":"

Published: printed in an official source.
Strict: enforced without exceptions.
Judicial: approved by a court.

","correct":false,"explanation":"Publication alone is insufficient, and strict enforcement or judicial approval does not replace the required qualities. The basis must be accessible, foreseeable, and safeguarded against arbitrariness."},{"text":"

Parliamentary: passed by Parliament.
Detailed: contains extensive wording.
Uniform: applies identically in every case.

","correct":false,"explanation":"These features concern the law’s authority or drafting style, not the full legal-basis test. People must be able to find and predict its use, with safeguards limiting arbitrary discretion."}]},{"id":"640d6192-cef7-4c1c-bda1-0427e15b8322","cardType":"basic","points":2,"front":"Why were the stop-and-search powers in Gillan and Quinton not in accordance with law?","back":"They were too broad and lacked sufficient safeguards.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"They were too broad and lacked sufficient safeguards.","correct":true,"explanation":"The powers gave officers excessive discretion without adequate legal protections against arbitrary use. This meant the interference was not sufficiently foreseeable or constrained to be in accordance with law."},{"text":"They were too narrow and required individual suspicion.","correct":false,"explanation":"The problem was excessive breadth, not narrowness or a requirement for individual suspicion. The powers were too broad and lacked sufficient safeguards against arbitrary interference."},{"text":"They were never published and lacked parliamentary approval.","correct":false,"explanation":"The judgment did not turn on non-publication or an absence of parliamentary approval. The powers were not in accordance with law because they were too broad and lacked sufficient safeguards."},{"text":"They were used too rarely and lacked operational guidance.","correct":false,"explanation":"The frequency of use was not the decisive issue, and operational guidance alone would not cure the problem. The powers were too broad and lacked sufficient safeguards."}]},{"id":"748eb403-d26d-4f4a-826f-d5b0a00d1a31","cardType":"basic","points":1,"front":"At the legitimate aim stage, what must the public authority’s reason match?","back":"A permitted aim listed in the relevant subsection .2.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"A permitted aim listed in the relevant subsection .2.","correct":true,"explanation":"Qualified Convention rights may be restricted only for the legitimate aims expressly listed in their second subsections. The authority’s stated reason must therefore correspond to one of those permitted aims."},{"text":"A general benefit identified by the public authority.","correct":false,"explanation":"A public authority cannot create its own broad justification for restricting a qualified right. Its reason must match a permitted aim listed in the relevant subsection .2."},{"text":"A political priority approved by the elected government.","correct":false,"explanation":"Government approval does not itself make a restriction pursue a legitimate Convention aim. The reason must match a permitted aim expressly listed in the relevant subsection .2."},{"text":"A reasonable objective recognised by domestic common law.","correct":false,"explanation":"Domestic reasonableness is not a substitute for the Convention’s exhaustive list of legitimate aims. The authority’s reason must match a permitted aim listed in the relevant subsection .2."}]},{"id":"4630f0a0-8afa-48e4-a19d-3be624c43202","cardType":"basic","points":2,"front":"Why is saying “public interest” alone insufficient for a restriction?","back":"The aim must fit a listed Article 8.2, 10.2 or 11.2 aim.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"The aim must fit a listed Article 8.2, 10.2 or 11.2 aim.","correct":true,"explanation":"“Public interest” is too general because qualified Convention rights identify specific legitimate aims. The authority must show that its objective fits an aim listed in the relevant Article’s second subsection."},{"text":"The aim must receive approval from Parliament before taking effect.","correct":false,"explanation":"Parliamentary approval does not replace the legitimate aim test under the Convention. The restriction’s objective must fit a listed Article 8.2, 10.2 or 11.2 aim."},{"text":"The aim must benefit every member of the public equally.","correct":false,"explanation":"A legitimate restriction need not benefit every person equally, but “public interest” cannot stand alone. The aim must fit a listed Article 8.2, 10.2 or 11.2 aim."},{"text":"The aim must be supported by a majority of public opinion.","correct":false,"explanation":"Popular support is not one of the Convention’s tests for a legitimate restriction. The objective must instead fit a listed Article 8.2, 10.2 or 11.2 aim."}]},{"id":"45b2692f-17e9-4766-b07d-994f1e09528e","cardType":"basic","points":1,"front":"Which Article 8.2 listed aim is absent from Article 11.2’s main list in these notes?","back":"Economic well-being.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"Economic well-being.","correct":true,"explanation":"Article 8.2 expressly includes the economic well-being of the country among its legitimate aims. That aim is absent from Article 11.2’s main list in these notes."},{"text":"National security.","correct":false,"explanation":"National security appears as a legitimate aim under both Article 8.2 and Article 11.2. The Article 8.2 aim absent from Article 11.2’s main list is economic well-being."},{"text":"Prevention of disorder.","correct":false,"explanation":"The prevention of disorder is included among Article 11.2’s legitimate aims, so it is not the missing item. The absent Article 8.2 aim is economic well-being."},{"text":"Protection of health.","correct":false,"explanation":"The protection of health is expressly included in Article 11.2’s list of legitimate aims. The Article 8.2 aim missing from that main list is economic well-being."}]},{"id":"9ffcc002-e414-4c31-8efa-c1cc849bbb66","cardType":"cloze","points":null,"front":"For courts, Article 10.2 includes maintaining [ ]; for leaks, it includes preventing disclosure of [ ].","back":"For courts, Article 10.2 includes maintaining authority and impartiality of the judiciary; for leaks, it includes preventing disclosure of confidential information.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"For courts, Article 10.2 includes maintaining authority and impartiality of the judiciary; for leaks, it includes preventing disclosure of confidential information.","correct":true,"explanation":"Article 10.2 expressly permits restrictions aimed at maintaining judicial authority and impartiality and at preventing the disclosure of confidential information, covering concerns about courts and leaks respectively."},{"text":"For courts, Article 10.2 includes maintaining public confidence in the government; for leaks, it includes preventing disclosure of confidential information.","correct":false,"explanation":"Public confidence in government is not the specified court-related aim. Article 10.2 refers to maintaining the authority and impartiality of the judiciary, alongside preventing disclosure of confidential information."},{"text":"For courts, Article 10.2 includes maintaining authority and impartiality of the judiciary; for leaks, it includes preventing disclosure of politically embarrassing information.","correct":false,"explanation":"Political embarrassment alone is not a listed Article 10.2 aim for restricting leaks. The provision permits preventing disclosure of confidential information and maintaining judicial authority and impartiality."},{"text":"For courts, Article 10.2 includes maintaining independence and efficiency of Parliament; for leaks, it includes preventing disclosure of officially disputed information.","correct":false,"explanation":"This confuses the judiciary with Parliament and treats disputed information as automatically protected. The listed aims are maintaining judicial authority and impartiality and preventing disclosure of confidential information."}]},{"id":"2f4c459e-4383-440c-95e9-e4de43856fcf","cardType":"basic","points":1,"front":"What extra lawful restriction does Article 11.2 allow for certain state personnel?","back":"Restrictions on armed forces, police, or state administration.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"Restrictions on armed forces, police, or state administration.","correct":true,"explanation":"Article 11.2 specifically allows lawful restrictions on the exercise of association rights by members of the armed forces, police, and state administration because of their public functions."},{"text":"Restrictions on judges, lawyers, or court administration.","correct":false,"explanation":"Article 11.2 does not state this as its special personnel exception. The additional lawful restrictions apply to the armed forces, police, and state administration."},{"text":"Restrictions on journalists, publishers, or broadcasting administration.","correct":false,"explanation":"Media personnel are not the groups identified by Article 11.2’s special restriction. The provision instead names the armed forces, police, and state administration."},{"text":"Restrictions on teachers, doctors, or local administration.","correct":false,"explanation":"This wrongly extends the exception to broad public-service professions and local administration. Article 11.2 specifically permits restrictions concerning the armed forces, police, or state administration."}]},{"id":"9b6053f2-937a-44c2-9835-ad102c307cdb","cardType":"cloze","points":null,"front":"In Sunday Times v UK [1979], necessity was linked to a [ ], not something merely [ ].","back":"In Sunday Times v UK [1979], necessity was linked to a pressing social need, not something merely helpful or convenient.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"In Sunday Times v UK [1979], necessity was linked to a pressing social need, not something merely helpful or convenient.","correct":true,"explanation":"The case established that necessity requires a pressing social need. A measure is not necessary merely because authorities consider it useful, helpful, or administratively convenient."},{"text":"In Sunday Times v UK [1979], necessity was linked to a general public preference, not something merely helpful or convenient.","correct":false,"explanation":"Public preference is not the legal threshold for necessity under the Convention. Sunday Times linked necessity to a pressing social need, rather than something merely helpful or convenient."},{"text":"In Sunday Times v UK [1979], necessity was linked to a pressing social need, not something merely unpopular or controversial.","correct":false,"explanation":"Unpopularity or controversy does not describe the inadequate threshold rejected by the Court. Necessity requires a pressing social need, not a measure that is merely helpful or convenient."},{"text":"In Sunday Times v UK [1979], necessity was linked to a reasonable political objective, not something merely desirable or inexpensive.","correct":false,"explanation":"A reasonable political objective is weaker than the Convention standard, while cost is not the comparison being made. The case requires a pressing social need, not mere helpfulness or convenience."}]},{"id":"7d52c71f-31eb-4536-acb1-df277178781d","cardType":"cloze","points":null,"front":"In Handyside v UK [1976], Article 10 protects expression that may "[ ]", though restrictions may still be [ ].","back":"In Handyside v UK [1976], Article 10 protects expression that may "offend, shock or disturb", though restrictions may still be justified.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"In Handyside v UK [1976], Article 10 protects expression that may "offend, shock or disturb", though restrictions may still be justified.","correct":true,"explanation":"Handyside confirms that freedom of expression protects ideas that offend, shock, or disturb, reflecting pluralism and tolerance. However, an interference may still be justified under Article 10.2."},{"text":"In Handyside v UK [1976], Article 10 protects expression that may "inform, educate or entertain", though restrictions may still be justified.","correct":false,"explanation":"This familiar media phrase misses Handyside’s emphasis on challenging expression. The case protects expression that may offend, shock, or disturb, although restrictions can still be justified."},{"text":"In Handyside v UK [1976], Article 10 protects expression that may "offend, shock or disturb", though restrictions may still be automatically lawful.","correct":false,"explanation":"Restrictions are not automatically lawful simply because expression is offensive or disturbing. They must satisfy Article 10.2, so they may be justified only when all relevant requirements are met."},{"text":"In Handyside v UK [1976], Article 10 protects expression that may "criticise, question or embarrass", though restrictions may still be politically desirable.","correct":false,"explanation":"Those words are not the established Handyside formulation, and political desirability is not enough to restrict expression. The case refers to expression that may offend, shock, or disturb and justified restrictions."}]},{"id":"d1ebca5a-3b29-47b3-a524-2b1ac755e240","cardType":"basic","points":2,"front":"What does proportionality require in a restriction case?","back":"

No further than needed for the legitimate aim.
Fair balance between individual and community.

","mcqOptions":[{"text":"

No further than needed for the legitimate aim.
Fair balance between individual and community.

","correct":true,"explanation":"Proportionality requires the restriction to be no more intrusive than necessary and to strike a fair balance between the individual’s rights and the community’s interests."},{"text":"

Any rational connection to the legitimate aim.
Complete priority for community interests.

","correct":false,"explanation":"A rational connection alone is insufficient, and community interests do not automatically prevail. The measure must go no further than needed and strike a fair balance."},{"text":"

Absolute necessity in every individual case.
Equal outcomes for individual and community.

","correct":false,"explanation":"Proportionality does not demand absolute necessity or mathematically equal outcomes. It requires no more interference than needed and a fair balance between competing interests."},{"text":"

Parliamentary approval for the legitimate aim.
No judicial review of the balance.

","correct":false,"explanation":"Legislative approval does not itself establish proportionality, and courts may review the balance. The restriction must go no further than needed and fairly balance the interests."}]},{"id":"5afbdb14-0da2-4339-99aa-82cf65a344f6","cardType":"basic","points":2,"front":"Which Bank Mellat question checks whether the restriction is unnecessarily intrusive?","back":"Whether a less intrusive measure could have been used.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"Whether a less intrusive measure could have been used.","correct":true,"explanation":"This question tests necessity by asking whether the legitimate aim could have been achieved through an equally effective measure that interfered less with the protected right."},{"text":"Whether the objective was sufficiently important to justify limiting a right.","correct":false,"explanation":"This is the first Bank Mellat question about the objective’s importance, not unnecessary intrusion. That issue asks whether a less intrusive measure could have been used."},{"text":"Whether the measure was rationally connected to the stated objective.","correct":false,"explanation":"This tests whether the restriction logically advances its objective, not whether it is unnecessarily intrusive. Intrusiveness is assessed by considering an available less intrusive measure."},{"text":"Whether a fair balance was struck between rights and interests.","correct":false,"explanation":"This concerns proportionality overall and the balance between harm and benefit. Unnecessary intrusion is specifically tested by asking whether a less intrusive measure was available."}]},{"id":"a74fa760-f8f7-4388-bb98-516aa21bf05a","cardType":"basic","points":2,"front":"Why did the policy in S and Marper v UK breach Article 8?","back":"Blanket, indefinite retention of unconvicted people’s fingerprints and DNA was disproportionate.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"Blanket, indefinite retention of unconvicted people’s fingerprints and DNA was disproportionate.","correct":true,"explanation":"The indiscriminate and indefinite retention applied regardless of circumstances or seriousness, failing to balance crime prevention against the privacy rights of people who had not been convicted."},{"text":"Targeted, time-limited retention of convicted people’s fingerprints and DNA was disproportionate.","correct":false,"explanation":"The case did not condemn targeted, limited retention concerning convicted people. The breach arose from blanket, indefinite retention of fingerprints and DNA belonging to unconvicted people."},{"text":"Temporary police collection of arrested people’s fingerprints and DNA was disproportionate.","correct":false,"explanation":"The central problem was not merely collecting samples following arrest. Article 8 was breached because unconvicted people’s data was then retained indiscriminately and indefinitely."},{"text":"Case-by-case deletion of unconvicted people’s fingerprints and DNA was disproportionate.","correct":false,"explanation":"A case-by-case deletion system would provide individual assessment rather than blanket treatment. The actual breach resulted from blanket, indefinite retention of unconvicted people’s data."}]},{"id":"f746c043-c0bc-4584-8391-c04cc6adf3b2","cardType":"basic","points":2,"front":"In Campbell v MGN, what made the newspaper’s Article 10 claim lose to Article 8 privacy?","back":"Publishing details and photos of medical treatment went too far.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"Publishing details and photos of medical treatment went too far.","correct":true,"explanation":"Although correcting Campbell’s misleading public statements could justify reporting her addiction and treatment, the additional treatment details and covert photographs intruded excessively into her private life."},{"text":"Publishing the fact of her drug addiction went too far.","correct":false,"explanation":"Publication of the basic fact was justified because Campbell had publicly denied taking drugs. The privacy breach arose from the additional treatment details and photographs."},{"text":"Publishing criticism of her false public statements went too far.","correct":false,"explanation":"Article 10 protected correcting Campbell’s misleading public claims about drug use. The newspaper lost because it also published intrusive medical-treatment details and covert photographs."},{"text":"Publishing her name and modelling career went too far.","correct":false,"explanation":"Campbell’s identity and modelling career were already public and were not the decisive privacy intrusion. The excessive element was publishing details and photographs of her medical treatment."}]},{"id":"dd01841d-ee84-43a7-9e15-01c759d459b0","cardType":"basic","points":2,"front":"Why was the interference unlawful in R (Laporte)?","back":"Police turned protesters back before any breach of the peace was imminent.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"Police turned protesters back before any breach of the peace was imminent.","correct":true,"explanation":"The police acted too early because their preventive common-law power required an imminent breach of the peace. Without imminence, stopping and returning the protesters was unlawful."},{"text":"Police turned protesters back after a breach of the peace had begun.","correct":false,"explanation":"Police may intervene where a breach of the peace is occurring or imminent. In Laporte, the unlawfulness arose because protesters were stopped before any breach was imminent."},{"text":"Police turned protesters back because the demonstration lacked prior authorisation.","correct":false,"explanation":"The decision was not based on a general requirement for prior authorisation. Police acted unlawfully because no breach of the peace was imminent when they stopped the protesters."},{"text":"Police turned protesters back after the protesters committed violent offences.","correct":false,"explanation":"The protesters had not committed violent offences justifying their removal. The police intervention was premature because a breach of the peace was not yet imminent."}]},{"id":"460b32b9-2161-4ac6-87bb-454adfc7e146","cardType":"basic","points":2,"front":"Why can broad or uncertain restrictions harm Articles 10 and 11?","back":"They may create a chilling effect on lawful speech or protest.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"They may create a chilling effect on lawful speech or protest.","correct":true,"explanation":"Unclear or excessively broad restrictions may deter people from exercising lawful expression and assembly because they fear punishment or cannot predict whether their conduct is prohibited."},{"text":"They may impose strict liability for every instance of lawful speech or protest.","correct":false,"explanation":"Broadness or uncertainty does not automatically impose strict liability. The principal rights concern is a chilling effect, as people may avoid lawful expression or protest through fear."},{"text":"They may remove the margin of appreciation from all regulation of lawful speech or protest.","correct":false,"explanation":"Uncertain restrictions do not automatically remove the state’s margin of appreciation. They risk creating a chilling effect by deterring lawful speech and protest through unclear boundaries."},{"text":"They may create an automatic entitlement to damages for lawful speech or protest.","correct":false,"explanation":"A broad restriction does not automatically entitle affected people to damages. Its immediate danger is a chilling effect that discourages lawful speech or protest before any claim occurs."}]}]}],"examCountdown":{"examDate":"2027-05-20","paperLabel":"Paper 1"},"heading":"Restrictions","title":"Restrictions Flashcards","topbar":{"backHref":"/a-level/law/aqa/flashcards"},"topicSidebar":"$L36"}]}],"topicId":"9b3723ba-672c-541e-b5c1-b9104cd15cf5","walled":"$L37"}],"$L38","$L39"]