32:I[196793,["/_next/static/chunks/075vy1fh16gh5.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/060-i_62-vse1.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2epfhfe5im7r6.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2yhf9vq09dqoa.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0p4rexedanx97.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0u008gt6051u7.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1odwrcl12kfnl.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0zkcxwtbsqliz.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/316m85d5s15pp.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2_itvjgqsumf8.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2wptr05dvvad-.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3r5hh4t0jf4es.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3ml3vooxhiupb.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1h4wccj42vygd.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/12xoy6h_w_le6.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2os7nxouq91eq.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3ht89vb0p09bm.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3ocoqwe4aht_u.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/32qmkt01ta8b2.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3jpl-42mbad5n.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1bbv7o2-m-0ni.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/097slu7xaeast.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0shhrr8zrsvma.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0j1q2_fxvgx28.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/14kf-an-d2n-e.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0v4byuex1x38h.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0mgw5qzpc_1eu.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/09_ag440ieydu.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0gvj8_2lj8s8m.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/04zr-wqafvwoa.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0llqhg6-bxn_b.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2ydqdr10ndcei.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1ku-vdy4ggo41.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2dx-vzwyw9a3g.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/32i_8fssnjnil.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2eoustw-nfu98.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1oz24qjw4uq89.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0k-y_4mcfub-p.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0itrgb6vzmww0.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/00ol_16j3a2oa.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0odk_0my0_b5-.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0dbk553rgd90s.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0aq3eylxphp57.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2srfni4gkx9g6.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3k8iy5tn80za8.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2hccrcvndngge.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3h4suq-9gmzwh.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/12mv6p8rwcl5o.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1bt82o91jhwht.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1nnw6yom6-qhh.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2vg15qyptj-oc.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2_vtmw66zj1j7.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0ep4vrgb00zlb.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2s1hkstzlmj2o.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2wp4esku6l29e.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/43ajf4ofaeu5y.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1lsxkfxy262n-.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0zg1om_k0m5zv.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1__39-dgg7p8-.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2gb4dscyul4eg.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1y5xmyjgu8grb.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2y341-r8ncizo.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0kpd0j3i_7yor.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1ksyn9m68446d.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0sf7rskx57j6y.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3wqp-h5xnebw9.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3ghbpnibq2fva.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/30dopbgd1dkf9.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947"],"Gingerbread"] 34:I[647935,["/_next/static/chunks/075vy1fh16gh5.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/060-i_62-vse1.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2epfhfe5im7r6.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2yhf9vq09dqoa.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0p4rexedanx97.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0u008gt6051u7.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1odwrcl12kfnl.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0zkcxwtbsqliz.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/316m85d5s15pp.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2_itvjgqsumf8.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2wptr05dvvad-.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3r5hh4t0jf4es.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3ml3vooxhiupb.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1h4wccj42vygd.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/12xoy6h_w_le6.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2os7nxouq91eq.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3ht89vb0p09bm.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3ocoqwe4aht_u.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/32qmkt01ta8b2.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3jpl-42mbad5n.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1bbv7o2-m-0ni.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/097slu7xaeast.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0shhrr8zrsvma.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0j1q2_fxvgx28.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/14kf-an-d2n-e.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0v4byuex1x38h.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0mgw5qzpc_1eu.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/09_ag440ieydu.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0gvj8_2lj8s8m.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/04zr-wqafvwoa.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0llqhg6-bxn_b.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2ydqdr10ndcei.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1ku-vdy4ggo41.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2dx-vzwyw9a3g.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/32i_8fssnjnil.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2eoustw-nfu98.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1oz24qjw4uq89.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0k-y_4mcfub-p.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0itrgb6vzmww0.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/00ol_16j3a2oa.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0odk_0my0_b5-.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0dbk553rgd90s.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0aq3eylxphp57.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2srfni4gkx9g6.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3k8iy5tn80za8.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2hccrcvndngge.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3h4suq-9gmzwh.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/12mv6p8rwcl5o.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1bt82o91jhwht.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1nnw6yom6-qhh.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2vg15qyptj-oc.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2_vtmw66zj1j7.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0ep4vrgb00zlb.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2s1hkstzlmj2o.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2wp4esku6l29e.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/43ajf4ofaeu5y.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1lsxkfxy262n-.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0zg1om_k0m5zv.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1__39-dgg7p8-.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2gb4dscyul4eg.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1y5xmyjgu8grb.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2y341-r8ncizo.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0kpd0j3i_7yor.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1ksyn9m68446d.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0sf7rskx57j6y.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3wqp-h5xnebw9.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3ghbpnibq2fva.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/30dopbgd1dkf9.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947"],"RecordResourceResume"] 35:I[830476,["/_next/static/chunks/075vy1fh16gh5.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/060-i_62-vse1.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2epfhfe5im7r6.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2yhf9vq09dqoa.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0p4rexedanx97.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0u008gt6051u7.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1odwrcl12kfnl.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0zkcxwtbsqliz.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/316m85d5s15pp.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2_itvjgqsumf8.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2wptr05dvvad-.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3r5hh4t0jf4es.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3ml3vooxhiupb.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1h4wccj42vygd.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/12xoy6h_w_le6.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2os7nxouq91eq.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3ht89vb0p09bm.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3ocoqwe4aht_u.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/32qmkt01ta8b2.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3jpl-42mbad5n.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1bbv7o2-m-0ni.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/097slu7xaeast.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0shhrr8zrsvma.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0j1q2_fxvgx28.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/14kf-an-d2n-e.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0v4byuex1x38h.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0mgw5qzpc_1eu.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/09_ag440ieydu.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0gvj8_2lj8s8m.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/04zr-wqafvwoa.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0llqhg6-bxn_b.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2ydqdr10ndcei.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1ku-vdy4ggo41.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2dx-vzwyw9a3g.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/32i_8fssnjnil.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2eoustw-nfu98.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1oz24qjw4uq89.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0k-y_4mcfub-p.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0itrgb6vzmww0.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/00ol_16j3a2oa.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0odk_0my0_b5-.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0dbk553rgd90s.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0aq3eylxphp57.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2srfni4gkx9g6.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3k8iy5tn80za8.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2hccrcvndngge.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3h4suq-9gmzwh.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/12mv6p8rwcl5o.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1bt82o91jhwht.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1nnw6yom6-qhh.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2vg15qyptj-oc.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2_vtmw66zj1j7.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0ep4vrgb00zlb.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2s1hkstzlmj2o.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2wp4esku6l29e.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/43ajf4ofaeu5y.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1lsxkfxy262n-.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0zg1om_k0m5zv.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1__39-dgg7p8-.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2gb4dscyul4eg.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1y5xmyjgu8grb.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2y341-r8ncizo.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0kpd0j3i_7yor.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1ksyn9m68446d.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0sf7rskx57j6y.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3wqp-h5xnebw9.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3ghbpnibq2fva.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/30dopbgd1dkf9.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947"],"FlashcardAccessBranch"] 36:I[315438,["/_next/static/chunks/075vy1fh16gh5.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/060-i_62-vse1.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2epfhfe5im7r6.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2yhf9vq09dqoa.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0p4rexedanx97.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0u008gt6051u7.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1odwrcl12kfnl.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0zkcxwtbsqliz.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/316m85d5s15pp.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2_itvjgqsumf8.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2wptr05dvvad-.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3r5hh4t0jf4es.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3ml3vooxhiupb.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1h4wccj42vygd.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/12xoy6h_w_le6.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2os7nxouq91eq.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3ht89vb0p09bm.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3ocoqwe4aht_u.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/32qmkt01ta8b2.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3jpl-42mbad5n.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1bbv7o2-m-0ni.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/097slu7xaeast.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0shhrr8zrsvma.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0j1q2_fxvgx28.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/14kf-an-d2n-e.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0v4byuex1x38h.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0mgw5qzpc_1eu.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/09_ag440ieydu.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0gvj8_2lj8s8m.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/04zr-wqafvwoa.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0llqhg6-bxn_b.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2ydqdr10ndcei.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1ku-vdy4ggo41.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2dx-vzwyw9a3g.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/32i_8fssnjnil.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2eoustw-nfu98.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1oz24qjw4uq89.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0k-y_4mcfub-p.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0itrgb6vzmww0.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/00ol_16j3a2oa.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0odk_0my0_b5-.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0dbk553rgd90s.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0aq3eylxphp57.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2srfni4gkx9g6.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3k8iy5tn80za8.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2hccrcvndngge.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3h4suq-9gmzwh.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/12mv6p8rwcl5o.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1bt82o91jhwht.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1nnw6yom6-qhh.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2vg15qyptj-oc.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2_vtmw66zj1j7.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0ep4vrgb00zlb.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2s1hkstzlmj2o.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2wp4esku6l29e.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/43ajf4ofaeu5y.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1lsxkfxy262n-.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0zg1om_k0m5zv.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1__39-dgg7p8-.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2gb4dscyul4eg.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1y5xmyjgu8grb.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/2y341-r8ncizo.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0kpd0j3i_7yor.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/1ksyn9m68446d.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/0sf7rskx57j6y.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3wqp-h5xnebw9.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/3ghbpnibq2fva.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947","/_next/static/chunks/30dopbgd1dkf9.js?dpl=nogit-1790172947"],"TopicFlashcardRunner"] 23:[["$","$L32",null,{"feature":"flashcards"}],"$L33",["$","$L34",null,{"href":"/a-level/law/aqa/human-rights-in-international-law/flashcards","label":"Human Rights in international law","subjectCode":"a_level_law__aqa","surface":"flashcards"}],["$","$L35",null,{"runner":["$","div",null,{"className":"min-h-0 flex-1 overflow-hidden bg-background","children":["$","$L36",null,{"decks":[{"id":"ffad1db2-3dad-48ff-9c04-f4da6875a23d","title":"Human Rights in international law Flashcards","topicId":"352a7958-1590-5525-a420-e6032aef5c46","topicSlug":"human-rights-in-international-law","cards":[{"id":"cd5629c0-78f6-424f-b41e-0d5394747fdd","cardType":"basic","points":1,"front":"Which event made international human rights protection politically urgent after 1945?","back":"The Second World War.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"The Second World War.","correct":true,"explanation":"The atrocities of the Second World War, particularly the Holocaust, demonstrated the need for international standards protecting individuals even when their own states and laws failed them."},{"text":"The First World War.","correct":false,"explanation":"The First World War encouraged international cooperation through the League of Nations, but the atrocities of the Second World War made universal human rights protection politically urgent after 1945."},{"text":"The Cold War.","correct":false,"explanation":"The Cold War influenced later disagreements about human rights, but the immediate catalyst after 1945 was the Second World War and its state-sponsored atrocities."},{"text":"The Great Depression.","correct":false,"explanation":"The Great Depression caused severe economic and political instability, but the Second World War exposed how states could use domestic law to carry out systematic oppression."}]},{"id":"5f88cadc-1840-49d8-beca-6cc1c6fcb4a5","cardType":"cloze","points":null,"front":"Before the Second World War, individual protection was mostly treated as a matter of [ ], but international human rights law claims there are [ ] for all humans.","back":"Before the Second World War, individual protection was mostly treated as a matter of domestic law, but international human rights law claims there are minimum standards for all humans.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"Before the Second World War, individual protection was mostly treated as a matter of domestic law, but international human rights law claims there are minimum standards for all humans.","correct":true,"explanation":"Rights were traditionally regarded as matters within each state’s jurisdiction. International human rights law instead establishes minimum standards that apply to every human being regardless of domestic law."},{"text":"Before the Second World War, individual protection was mostly treated as a matter of international law, but international human rights law claims there are minimum standards for all humans.","correct":false,"explanation":"Treating pre-war protection as primarily international reverses the historical position. It was mainly governed by domestic law, while modern international human rights law asserts minimum standards for everyone."},{"text":"Before the Second World War, individual protection was mostly treated as a matter of domestic law, but international human rights law claims there are identical legal systems for all humans.","correct":false,"explanation":"International human rights law does not require every country to adopt an identical legal system. It establishes minimum standards that domestic systems must respect while allowing different legal arrangements."},{"text":"Before the Second World War, individual protection was mostly treated as a matter of religious law, but international human rights law claims there are universal privileges for all humans.","correct":false,"explanation":"The traditional legal position centred on domestic law, not religious law. International human rights law also recognises minimum standards and rights, rather than privileges granted selectively by authorities."}]},{"id":"c45708e8-32da-4f38-9fd6-31f8aea7014f","cardType":"basic","points":2,"front":"Why did the Second World War make domestic law alone seem inadequate for protecting rights?","back":"States could pass unjust laws or use legal systems for oppression.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"States could pass unjust laws or use legal systems for oppression.","correct":true,"explanation":"The Second World War showed that states could authorise persecution through valid domestic laws. International standards were therefore needed to assess state conduct beyond national legality."},{"text":"Courts could always strike down laws that breached moral rights.","correct":false,"explanation":"Domestic courts did not always possess or exercise power to invalidate oppressive laws. The problem was that states could legalise oppression, making standards beyond domestic law necessary."},{"text":"Individuals could choose which national legal system applied to them.","correct":false,"explanation":"Individuals generally remain subject to the law of the relevant state and cannot simply select another system. The real concern was that states could enact and enforce unjust laws."},{"text":"International organisations already had direct power to repeal oppressive national laws.","correct":false,"explanation":"International organisations did not already possess general authority to repeal national legislation. International human rights protection developed because states themselves could pass unjust laws and use courts oppressively."}]},{"id":"777aeb8c-741f-4632-8ac2-1d62521e608f","cardType":"basic","points":2,"front":"What did the Nuremberg trials reinforce about legal responsibility?","back":"People and states can be judged by standards beyond domestic law.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"People and states can be judged by standards beyond domestic law.","correct":true,"explanation":"The Nuremberg trials reinforced that domestic authorisation does not excuse international crimes. Individuals and states may be assessed under international standards even when national law permits their conduct."},{"text":"People and states can be judged by standards chosen by each defendant.","correct":false,"explanation":"Defendants cannot select the legal standards governing their own conduct. Nuremberg reinforced accountability under standards beyond domestic law, particularly international rules concerning serious crimes."},{"text":"People and states can be judged by domestic law and nothing else.","correct":false,"explanation":"This repeats the strict domestic-law approach that Nuremberg rejected. The trials demonstrated that conduct may be judged under international standards despite being authorised by national law."},{"text":"People and states can be judged by political opinion rather than law.","correct":false,"explanation":"Nuremberg aimed to establish legal responsibility, not judgment based merely on political preference. Its key principle was accountability under legal standards extending beyond domestic law."}]},{"id":"1a5e325a-ad02-42b1-99a4-561358242ba2","cardType":"cloze","points":null,"front":"The [ ] was created in [ ] after the Second World War.","back":"The United Nations was created in 1945 after the Second World War.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"The United Nations was created in 1945 after the Second World War.","correct":true,"explanation":"The United Nations was established in 1945 following the Second World War, with maintaining international peace and promoting respect for human rights among its central purposes."},{"text":"The League of Nations was created in 1945 after the Second World War.","correct":false,"explanation":"The League of Nations was established in 1920 after the First World War and was later replaced. The United Nations was the organisation created in 1945."},{"text":"The United Nations was created in 1949 after the Second World War.","correct":false,"explanation":"This confuses the UN’s founding date with the year associated with institutions such as NATO and the Council of Europe. The United Nations was created in 1945."},{"text":"The Council of Europe was created in 1945 after the Second World War.","correct":false,"explanation":"The Council of Europe was founded in 1949, not 1945. The international organisation established in 1945 immediately after the war was the United Nations."}]},{"id":"0cd11a61-962c-4dc4-a1ce-7e1120f893ae","cardType":"basic","points":2,"front":"Why did the UDHR become important despite the UN Charter mentioning human rights?","back":"The Charter did not give a full list of individual rights.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"The Charter did not give a full list of individual rights.","correct":true,"explanation":"Although the UN Charter referred to human rights, it did not identify a comprehensive catalogue of individual entitlements. The UDHR supplied a detailed statement of those rights."},{"text":"The Charter protected only rights arising during armed conflict.","correct":false,"explanation":"The Charter’s human rights commitments were not restricted to wartime, although they lacked detail. The UDHR became important because the Charter contained no full list of individual rights."},{"text":"The Charter made every human right directly enforceable in national courts.","correct":false,"explanation":"The Charter did not make a complete set of rights automatically enforceable in domestic courts. The UDHR was needed to articulate a fuller catalogue of individual rights."},{"text":"The Charter contained a complete and detailed catalogue of individual rights.","correct":false,"explanation":"This reverses the reason for adopting the UDHR. The Charter mentioned human rights in broad terms but did not provide a full, detailed list of individual rights."}]},{"id":"a57ba997-ab72-4fde-9c76-11b2d9ece6b6","cardType":"cloze","points":null,"front":"The UDHR was adopted by the [ ] in [ ].","back":"The UDHR was adopted by the UN General Assembly in 1948.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"The UDHR was adopted by the UN General Assembly in 1948.","correct":true,"explanation":"The UN General Assembly adopted the Universal Declaration of Human Rights on 10 December 1948, setting out a common international standard of rights for all people."},{"text":"The UDHR was adopted by the UN Security Council in 1948.","correct":false,"explanation":"This confuses the functions of two principal UN organs. The UDHR was adopted by the UN General Assembly, not the Security Council, in 1948."},{"text":"The UDHR was adopted by the UN General Assembly in 1950.","correct":false,"explanation":"The adopting body is correct, but the date is two years too late. The UN General Assembly adopted the UDHR in 1948."},{"text":"The UDHR was adopted by the UN Security Council in 1950.","correct":false,"explanation":"Both details are mistaken: the Security Council did not adopt the declaration, and 1950 is too late. The UN General Assembly adopted it in 1948."}]},{"id":"9c28b362-2346-46c2-9a77-3cd2b727cb8e","cardType":"basic","points":1,"front":"What is the core legal status of the UDHR?","back":"It is declaratory and influential, not directly enforceable as a treaty.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"It is declaratory and influential, not directly enforceable as a treaty.","correct":true,"explanation":"The UDHR is a declaration rather than a binding treaty, so it is not directly enforceable on that basis. Nevertheless, it has strongly influenced treaties, constitutions and customary law."},{"text":"It is legally binding on every state, and directly enforceable as a treaty.","correct":false,"explanation":"This confuses a declaration with a treaty. The UDHR is not itself directly enforceable as a treaty, although it is highly influential and has shaped binding legal instruments."},{"text":"It is a regional European convention, directly enforceable by the European Court.","correct":false,"explanation":"This confuses the UDHR with the European Convention on Human Rights. The UDHR is a global UN declaration that is influential but not directly treaty-enforceable."},{"text":"It is non-binding and legally irrelevant, with no influence on later human rights law.","correct":false,"explanation":"Although the UDHR is not itself a directly enforceable treaty, calling it legally irrelevant overlooks its major influence on later treaties, national constitutions and customary international law."}]},{"id":"be2a8a89-d103-4f81-9e09-caba47a9efab","cardType":"basic","points":1,"front":"What does Article 1 UDHR say about all human beings?","back":"They are born free and equal in dignity and rights.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"They are born free and equal in dignity and rights.","correct":true,"explanation":"Article 1 UDHR establishes that every human being enters the world with equal inherent worth and the same fundamental rights, without distinctions based on status or privilege."},{"text":"They are born free and equal in status and wealth.","correct":false,"explanation":"Replacing dignity and rights with legal status and property introduces conditions not found in Article 1. The provision affirms that people are born free and equal in dignity and rights."},{"text":"They are born free and equal in education and opportunity.","correct":false,"explanation":"Article 1 does not say that people are born equal in education or opportunity; those outcomes vary. It specifically recognises freedom and equality in dignity and rights."},{"text":"They are born free and equal in political power and social position.","correct":false,"explanation":"The UDHR does not guarantee equal political power or social position from birth. Article 1 instead protects the universal starting point of freedom and equal dignity and rights."}]},{"id":"a9ec72f7-3613-4044-ae33-36310c1e9fdc","cardType":"cloze","points":null,"front":"Article 3 UDHR protects the right to [ ], while Article 5 UDHR protects freedom from [ ].","back":"Article 3 UDHR protects the right to life, liberty and security of person, while Article 5 UDHR protects freedom from torture or cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"Article 3 UDHR protects the right to life, liberty and security of person, while Article 5 UDHR protects freedom from torture or cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment.","correct":true,"explanation":"Article 3 protects life, liberty and personal security, while Article 5 prohibits torture and cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment. Together, these provisions protect physical integrity and basic freedom."},{"text":"Article 3 UDHR protects the right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion, while Article 5 UDHR protects freedom from arbitrary arrest or detention.","correct":false,"explanation":"Freedom of thought and religion belongs to Article 18, not Article 3, and arbitrary detention is addressed elsewhere. Article 5 specifically names torture and cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment."},{"text":"Article 3 UDHR protects the right to property and nationality, while Article 5 UDHR protects freedom from slavery or forced labour.","correct":false,"explanation":"Article 3 does not guarantee property or nationality, and Article 5 does not concern forced labour. The correct protections are life, liberty and security, and freedom from torture or ill-treatment."},{"text":"Article 3 UDHR protects the right to peaceful assembly and association, while Article 5 UDHR protects freedom from arbitrary expulsion from a country.","correct":false,"explanation":"Peaceful assembly is protected by Article 20, while expulsion concerns movement and residence rights. Article 3 covers life, liberty and security, and Article 5 prohibits torture or degrading treatment."}]},{"id":"f2d773ae-24a9-4189-b55b-415355fbc93d","cardType":"basic","points":2,"front":"What was the UDHR’s wider impact after 1948?","back":"

It gave rights a shared international language.
It influenced later binding treaties.

","mcqOptions":[{"text":"

It gave rights a shared international language.
It influenced later binding treaties.

","correct":true,"explanation":"The UDHR provided a common vocabulary for discussing human rights internationally and helped inspire later treaties that imposed binding legal obligations on states."},{"text":"

It created a single international court.
It imposed immediate criminal penalties.

","correct":false,"explanation":"The UDHR did not create a single world court or automatically impose criminal penalties. Its major impact was linguistic and normative, including its influence on later binding treaties."},{"text":"

It abolished national sovereignty.
It established a global government.

","correct":false,"explanation":"The declaration did not abolish national sovereignty or establish one global government. Its wider significance was setting shared standards and influencing later binding human rights treaties."},{"text":"

It made all rights directly enforceable domestically.
It replaced national constitutions.

","correct":false,"explanation":"The UDHR did not make every listed right directly enforceable in domestic courts. It created shared international language and influenced the development of binding treaties."}]},{"id":"346d9be0-b860-41d8-aee5-b39e368bc0cd","cardType":"basic","points":1,"front":"Why is it wrong to describe the ECHR as part of EU law?","back":"The ECHR belongs to the Council of Europe, not the EU.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"The ECHR belongs to the Council of Europe, not the EU.","correct":true,"explanation":"The ECHR is a treaty created within the Council of Europe, a separate organisation from the European Union. Confusing the two organisations leads to the wrong legal classification."},{"text":"The ECHR belongs to the European Union, not the Council of Europe.","correct":false,"explanation":"The ECHR is not an EU instrument. It belongs to the Council of Europe, which is a distinct international organisation with a wider membership than the EU."},{"text":"The ECHR belongs to the United Nations, not the Council of Europe.","correct":false,"explanation":"The ECHR is not administered by the United Nations. It belongs to the Council of Europe, while the UN adopted the separate Universal Declaration of Human Rights."},{"text":"The ECHR belongs to the United Kingdom Parliament, not the Council of Europe.","correct":false,"explanation":"The ECHR was not created by the domestic law of the United Kingdom. It is a regional treaty belonging to the Council of Europe, separate from both UK law and the EU."}]},{"id":"fd57354a-f4af-46aa-9c2c-882b9b3c6a15","cardType":"cloze","points":null,"front":"The ECHR opened for signature in [ ] and entered into force in [ ].","back":"The ECHR opened for signature in 1950 and entered into force in 1953.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"The ECHR opened for signature in 1950 and entered into force in 1953.","correct":true,"explanation":"The Convention was opened for signature in 1950 and subsequently entered into force in 1953, after the required ratifications and procedures had been completed."},{"text":"The ECHR opened for signature in 1953 and entered into force in 1950.","correct":false,"explanation":"This reverses the two dates. The ECHR was signed in 1950, but it did not enter into force until 1953 after the treaty requirements were met."},{"text":"The ECHR opened for signature in 1948 and entered into force in 1952.","correct":false,"explanation":"The first date is close but incorrect: the Convention opened for signature in 1950. Its later entry into force was in 1953, not 1952."},{"text":"The ECHR opened for signature in 1951 and entered into force in 1954.","correct":false,"explanation":"The Convention was not opened for signature in 1951, and its entry into force was not delayed until 1954. The established dates are 1950 and 1953."}]},{"id":"8a902d86-1658-485a-b969-eca76907848b","cardType":"basic","points":2,"front":"What key legal feature makes the ECHR stronger than the UDHR for an enforceable claim?","back":"The ECHR is a binding regional treaty.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"The ECHR is a binding regional treaty.","correct":true,"explanation":"Unlike the UDHR, which is a declaration, the ECHR is a binding regional treaty. States parties therefore undertake legal obligations capable of supporting enforceable claims."},{"text":"The ECHR is a non-binding political declaration.","correct":false,"explanation":"The ECHR is not merely a political statement. Its strength comes from being a binding regional treaty, whereas the UDHR is a declaration without the same treaty status."},{"text":"The ECHR is a universal global constitution.","correct":false,"explanation":"The ECHR does not operate as a universal global constitution. It is a binding regional treaty applying within its system of participating states."},{"text":"The ECHR is a domestic parliamentary statute.","correct":false,"explanation":"The ECHR is not simply a domestic statute passed by one national parliament. Its enforceability derives from its status as a binding regional treaty."}]},{"id":"4d305ad7-6f85-4e12-9be1-6002548ebc43","cardType":"basic","points":1,"front":"What does Article 1 ECHR require states to do?","back":"Secure Convention rights to everyone within their jurisdiction.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"Secure Convention rights to everyone within their jurisdiction.","correct":true,"explanation":"Article 1 ECHR requires each state party to secure the Convention’s rights to everyone within its jurisdiction, connecting state responsibility to the people it controls or governs."},{"text":"Secure Convention rights to everyone who holds their citizenship.","correct":false,"explanation":"Article 1 does not limit duties to citizens. States must secure Convention rights to everyone within their jurisdiction, including non-nationals in relevant circumstances."},{"text":"Secure Convention rights to everyone within their territory.","correct":false,"explanation":"The obligation is not restricted to people physically inside national territory in every case. Article 1 uses the broader concept of jurisdiction to define responsibility."},{"text":"Secure Convention rights to everyone within their courts.","correct":false,"explanation":"Article 1 does not require protection only for people who have exhausted domestic remedies. It requires rights to be secured to everyone within the state’s jurisdiction."}]},{"id":"53095857-ec9a-4c73-97d1-8eef574d7269","cardType":"cloze","points":null,"front":"Article 6 ECHR protects the right to a [ ], while Article 8 ECHR protects [ ].","back":"Article 6 ECHR protects the right to a fair trial, while Article 8 ECHR protects private and family life.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"Article 6 ECHR protects the right to a fair trial, while Article 8 ECHR protects private and family life.","correct":true,"explanation":"Article 6 protects a fair trial, while Article 8 safeguards private and family life. These are distinct Convention rights addressing justice and personal or family autonomy."},{"text":"Article 6 ECHR protects the right to a private and family life, while Article 8 ECHR protects a fair trial.","correct":false,"explanation":"Article 6 does not provide a general right to privacy, and Article 8 is not the fair-trial provision. The rights are fair trial under Article 6 and private and family life under Article 8."},{"text":"Article 6 ECHR protects the right to a freedom of expression, while Article 8 ECHR protects freedom from torture.","correct":false,"explanation":"Freedom of expression is primarily protected by Article 10, not Article 6, and Article 8 protects private and family life rather than freedom from torture."},{"text":"Article 6 ECHR protects the right to a liberty and security, while Article 8 ECHR protects peaceful assembly and association.","correct":false,"explanation":"Article 6 does not protect liberty and security as its central guarantee, and Article 8 does not protect peaceful assembly. The relevant rights are fair trial and private and family life."}]},{"id":"23cbdb37-ea26-445f-ac4a-dc8be9ce1295","cardType":"cloze","points":null,"front":"Article 10 ECHR protects [ ], while Article 11 ECHR protects [ ].","back":"Article 10 ECHR protects freedom of expression, while Article 11 ECHR protects freedom of assembly and association.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"Article 10 ECHR protects freedom of expression, while Article 11 ECHR protects freedom of assembly and association.","correct":true,"explanation":"Article 10 covers the communication and receipt of ideas, while Article 11 protects peaceful gatherings and the formation or membership of associations, including trade unions."},{"text":"Article 10 ECHR protects freedom of assembly and association, while Article 11 ECHR protects freedom of expression.","correct":false,"explanation":"This reverses the two provisions. Article 10 protects freedom of expression, whereas Article 11 protects freedom of peaceful assembly and freedom of association."},{"text":"Article 10 ECHR protects freedom of thought, conscience and religion, while Article 11 ECHR protects freedom of expression.","correct":false,"explanation":"Freedom of thought, conscience and religion belongs to Article 9, not Article 10. Article 10 protects expression, and Article 11 protects assembly and association."},{"text":"Article 10 ECHR protects respect for private and family life, while Article 11 ECHR protects freedom of thought, conscience and religion.","correct":false,"explanation":"This confuses Articles 8 and 9 with the relevant provisions. Article 10 protects expression, while Article 11 protects peaceful assembly and association."}]},{"id":"b3fbddc8-a69a-443f-b9af-f6dc28a2f399","cardType":"cloze","points":null,"front":"Under the ECHR, [ ] allows individual applications, and [ ] normally requires applicants to exhaust domestic remedies first.","back":"Under the ECHR, Article 34 allows individual applications, and Article 35 normally requires applicants to exhaust domestic remedies first.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"Under the ECHR, Article 34 allows individual applications, and Article 35 normally requires applicants to exhaust domestic remedies first.","correct":true,"explanation":"Article 34 establishes the individual application procedure before the European Court of Human Rights. Article 35 makes exhaustion of available domestic remedies a normal admissibility requirement."},{"text":"Under the ECHR, Article 35 allows individual applications, and Article 34 normally requires applicants to exhaust domestic remedies first.","correct":false,"explanation":"This swaps the provisions. Article 34 permits individual applications, while Article 35 contains admissibility conditions, including the normal requirement to exhaust domestic remedies."},{"text":"Under the ECHR, Article 33 allows individual applications, and Article 35 normally requires applicants to exhaust domestic remedies first.","correct":false,"explanation":"Article 33 concerns applications brought by one state against another, not individual applications. Individuals apply under Article 34, subject to Article 35 admissibility requirements."},{"text":"Under the ECHR, Article 34 allows individual applications, and Article 46 normally requires applicants to exhaust domestic remedies first.","correct":false,"explanation":"Article 46 concerns the binding force and execution of final judgments. The exhaustion of domestic remedies requirement is found in Article 35, while Article 34 permits individual applications."}]},{"id":"0b8818c8-1651-4c9d-98a9-56faf1f2ea5d","cardType":"basic","points":1,"front":"What effect does Article 46 ECHR give final European Court judgments?","back":"Final judgments are binding on the states involved.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"Final judgments are binding on the states involved.","correct":true,"explanation":"Article 46 requires states to abide by final European Court of Human Rights judgments in cases to which they are parties, making those judgments legally binding."},{"text":"Final judgments are advisory for the states involved.","correct":false,"explanation":"Advisory opinions are distinct from final judgments in contentious cases. Under Article 46, final judgments are binding on the states that were parties to the case."},{"text":"Final judgments are binding on all Council of Europe states.","correct":false,"explanation":"Article 46 directly binds the states involved in the particular case, not every Council of Europe state. Other states may consider the judgment, but are not parties to it."},{"text":"Final judgments are optional for the states involved.","correct":false,"explanation":"States do not have a legal choice about whether to follow final judgments against them. Article 46 requires the states involved to abide by those judgments."}]},{"id":"27d7a495-ca98-443f-8118-dabaeee158cb","cardType":"basic","points":2,"front":"For a banned peaceful political demonstration, why is the ECHR usually the stronger route than the UDHR?","back":"It gives enforceable rights under Article 10 and Article 11.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"It gives enforceable rights under Article 10 and Article 11.","correct":true,"explanation":"A peaceful political demonstration engages expression under Article 10 and peaceful assembly under Article 11. Unlike the UDHR, the ECHR provides a regional judicial enforcement mechanism."},{"text":"It gives enforceable rights under Article 8 and Article 9.","correct":false,"explanation":"Articles 8 and 9 protect private life and freedom of thought, conscience and religion. Political demonstrations are primarily protected by Articles 10 and 11."},{"text":"It gives enforceable rights under Article 5 and Article 6.","correct":false,"explanation":"Articles 5 and 6 concern liberty and security and the right to a fair trial. A ban on a peaceful demonstration primarily engages Articles 10 and 11."},{"text":"It gives enforceable rights under Article 12 and Article 14.","correct":false,"explanation":"Article 12 protects the right to marry, while Article 14 prohibits discrimination in Convention rights. Expression and peaceful assembly are specifically protected by Articles 10 and 11."}]},{"id":"86a9616a-06e9-4b54-8d53-1adf662fe78a","cardType":"basic","points":3,"front":"Under Articles 10.2 and 11.2 ECHR, what must a rights restriction be?","back":"

Lawful.
Pursuing a legitimate aim.
Necessary in a democratic society.

","mcqOptions":[{"text":"

Lawful.
Pursuing a legitimate aim.
Necessary in a democratic society.

","correct":true,"explanation":"Articles 10.2 and 11.2 require restrictions to be prescribed by law, directed towards a listed legitimate aim, and necessary and proportionate in a democratic society."},{"text":"

Lawful.
Pursuing any government policy.
Reasonable in a democratic society.

","correct":false,"explanation":"A general government policy is not automatically a legitimate aim, and mere reasonableness is insufficient. The restriction must pursue a recognised legitimate aim and be necessary in a democratic society."},{"text":"

Authorised by a minister.
Pursuing a legitimate aim.
Necessary in a democratic society.

","correct":false,"explanation":"Ministerial approval alone does not make an interference lawful. It must have an adequate legal basis, pursue a legitimate aim, and be necessary in a democratic society."},{"text":"

Lawful.
Pursuing a legitimate aim.
Popular in a democratic society.

","correct":false,"explanation":"Popularity is not the Convention test and cannot justify disproportionate interference with minority rights. The restriction must instead be necessary in a democratic society."}]},{"id":"5f5ffa5c-716a-43f7-85b9-06dec2b6350b","cardType":"basic","points":2,"front":"What did Soering v United Kingdom show about ECHR enforceability?","back":"The UK could not extradite where there was a real risk of Article 3 treatment.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"The UK could not extradite where there was a real risk of Article 3 treatment.","correct":true,"explanation":"Soering established that extradition may violate the ECHR where substantial grounds show a real risk of torture or inhuman or degrading treatment in the receiving state."},{"text":"The UK could not extradite where there was a real risk of Article 6 treatment.","correct":false,"explanation":"Article 6 protects fair trial rights rather than defining prohibited treatment. Soering concerned the real risk of inhuman or degrading treatment contrary to Article 3."},{"text":"The UK could not extradite where there was a real risk of Article 8 treatment.","correct":false,"explanation":"Article 8 protects private and family life, not freedom from torture or inhuman treatment. Soering prevented extradition because of the real risk of Article 3 treatment."},{"text":"The UK could not extradite where there was a real risk of Article 10 treatment.","correct":false,"explanation":"Article 10 protects freedom of expression and does not classify forms of prohibited treatment. Soering concerned a real risk of treatment contrary to Article 3."}]},{"id":"ca6dc623-dff1-4b45-90cb-a1757b60e73e","cardType":"basic","points":2,"front":"What practical enforcement limit remains even under the ECHR?","back":"The system depends heavily on state compliance with judgments.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"The system depends heavily on state compliance with judgments.","correct":true,"explanation":"Although Article 46 makes final judgments binding, implementation usually relies on states adopting the required legal, administrative or financial measures, supervised by the Committee of Ministers."},{"text":"The system depends heavily on individual applications with judgments.","correct":false,"explanation":"Individual applications allow cases to reach the Court, but they do not ensure implementation afterward. The practical enforcement limit is continued dependence on state compliance with judgments."},{"text":"The system depends heavily on domestic remedies with judgments.","correct":false,"explanation":"Exhausting domestic remedies is normally an admissibility requirement before an application reaches Strasbourg. Enforcement after judgment instead depends heavily on the state complying with the Court’s decision."},{"text":"The system depends heavily on judicial precedent with judgments.","correct":false,"explanation":"The Court’s case law helps interpret Convention rights, but precedent alone cannot implement remedies within states. Practical enforcement still relies heavily on state compliance with judgments."}]},{"id":"b6c87584-6041-4a03-b84e-4fba8224b66d","cardType":"basic","points":2,"front":"Why can international human rights law be criticised from a state sovereignty perspective?","back":"It can shift sensitive policy choices from national institutions to international courts.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"It can shift sensitive policy choices from national institutions to international courts.","correct":true,"explanation":"The sovereignty criticism is that international adjudication lets external courts review decisions made by domestic legislatures, governments and courts, reducing national control over politically sensitive policies."},{"text":"It can shift sensitive policy choices from international courts to national institutions.","correct":false,"explanation":"This reverses the sovereignty criticism. Critics argue that international human rights law moves authority away from national institutions and towards international courts."},{"text":"It can shift sensitive policy choices from national institutions to local authorities.","correct":false,"explanation":"Moving power between national and local bodies is an issue of domestic decentralisation, not international sovereignty. The criticism concerns transferring authority from national institutions to international courts."},{"text":"It can shift sensitive policy choices from private organisations to international courts.","correct":false,"explanation":"State sovereignty concerns the authority of national public institutions, not private organisations. The criticism is that international courts can override or constrain choices made through national institutions."}]},{"id":"7b5fb97e-b045-4e54-ac72-f2b33cbb92b3","cardType":"basic","points":2,"front":"What does the margin of appreciation allow states to do?","back":"Use discretion when balancing Convention rights against public interests.","mcqOptions":[{"text":"Use discretion when balancing Convention rights against public interests.","correct":true,"explanation":"The margin of appreciation gives national authorities limited discretion in applying Convention rights, recognising that they may be better placed to assess local needs and conditions, subject to European supervision."},{"text":"Use derogations whenever Convention rights conflict with public interests.","correct":false,"explanation":"States cannot suspend Convention rights whenever public interests are invoked. Temporary derogation is permitted only under Article 15 in strictly defined emergencies; the margin instead allows limited discretion in balancing rights."},{"text":"Avoid supervision when balancing Convention rights against public interests.","correct":false,"explanation":"The margin of appreciation does not remove supervision by the European Court of Human Rights. It permits limited national discretion, while the Court retains authority to decide whether Convention standards were respected."},{"text":"Use domestic law to redefine Convention rights around public interests.","correct":false,"explanation":"States cannot redefine the substance of Convention rights according to domestic preferences. The doctrine allows discretion in balancing protected rights against public interests, but only within limits set by the Convention."}]}]}],"examCountdown":{"examDate":"2027-05-20","paperLabel":"Paper 1"},"heading":"Human Rights in international law","title":"Human Rights in international law Flashcards","topbar":{"backHref":"/a-level/law/aqa/flashcards"},"topicSidebar":"$L37"}]}],"topicId":"352a7958-1590-5525-a420-e6032aef5c46","walled":"$L38"}],"$L39","$L3a"]