An investigator is given two unknown aqueous solutions, X and Y, each containing a different transition metal salt.
The investigator performs a series of chemical tests on both solutions. The observations are recorded in Table 1.
Table 1
| Test | Observations with X | Observations with Y |
|---|---|---|
| Add sodium hydroxide solution slowly until in excess. | A brown precipitate forms that is insoluble in excess. | A green precipitate forms that is insoluble in excess. |
| Add sodium carbonate solution. | A brown precipitate forms. Effervescence is observed. | A green precipitate forms. |
| Add dilute nitric acid and then divide each solution into two portions. | No visible change. | No visible change. |
| Add barium chloride solution to the first portion. | A white precipitate forms. | No visible change. |
| Add silver nitrate solution to the second portion. | No visible change. | A white precipitate forms. |
Identify the salts present in solutions X and Y using the information in Table 1.
In your answer, you should: